Fetter's Dairy Isle

Fetter's Dairy Isle is a hidden gem in Newark, Ohio, located at 471 W Church St, offering an array of delicious comfort foods and sweet treats that are sure to satisfy any craving. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty sandwich, a tasty burger, or a refreshing ice cream, this cozy spot has it all. Let’s take a closer look at what makes this local favorite stand out, from its menu to customer reviews.

Diverse Menu to Satisfy Every Craving

Fetter's Dairy Isle’s menu is as diverse as it is mouthwatering. Whether you’re craving a classic hot dog, such as the Coney Dog, or something more unique like a BBQ Onion Burger, there’s something for everyone. Their burgers range from the straightforward Hamburger to the indulgent Mushroom Swiss Burger, giving guests a variety of flavors to enjoy. For wing lovers, the Wing Dings and Boneless Wings are perfect choices, paired with sides like crispy Fries, Onion Rings, and Cheese Sticks.

When it comes to beverages, Fetter’s Dairy Isle has a delightful selection of Fountain Drinks, Root Beer Floats, and even more fun options like Boba Lemonade and Smoothies. If you’re in the mood for a sweet treat, the Twister sundae or the iconic Banana Split are perfect indulgences. And of course, the house specialty, Soft Serve Ice Cream, is always a hit, alongside unique offerings like Dole Whip Ice Cream and even the Doggy Sundae for your furry friends.

Services That Enhance Your Experience

What makes Fetter's Dairy Isle even more appealing is the convenience and thoughtful services it offers. They cater to busy locals by providing takeout options and accept credit cards and Apple Pay, making it easy for customers to enjoy their meals without hassle. The addition of Wi-Fi means you can stay connected while you munch on your favorites, and for those on the go, there’s even bike parking available.

If you’re planning a special event, Fetter's Dairy Isle also offers catering services, so you can bring the delicious taste of their menu to your gathering. The combination of quick service, accessible payment options, and flexible offerings make it a convenient and enjoyable spot for any occasion.

Raving Customer Reviews

It’s no surprise that Fetter's Dairy Isle has earned high praise from its customers. Many reviews highlight the exceptional ice cream and standout dishes. One satisfied customer, Jeannie I., mentioned, “I really love this small business. Their ice cream is so good, and sandwiches and sides are amazing...especially the funnel fries.” Another customer, Keith B., shared his enjoyment of their unique ice cream options, saying, “Coffee soft serve. Cocoa pebble twists. Or blizzards. Whatever noncopyrighted term they have to use… All in all... I'm glad I stopped and got a cocoa pebble blizzard and tried their coffee soft serve. So good.”

These reviews reflect the friendly atmosphere and quality food that keeps people coming back for more. Whether you’re enjoying a casual meal with friends or stopping by for a sweet treat, the experience at Fetter's Dairy Isle is sure to leave a lasting impression.