Fetter's Dairy Isle
  • Photos
  • Menu
  • Location
  • Work Hours
  • Business info
  • Reviews

Fetter's Dairy Isle Menu

Sandwiches

Hot Dog
$2.50
Foot Long Hot Dog
$3.45
Coney Dog
$3.25
Chicken Dog
$4.05
Hot dog with shredded chicken on top.
Footlong Chicken Dog
$5.05
Corn Dog
$3.25
Shredded Chicken Sandwich
$4.05
Sloppy Joe Sandwich
$4.05
BBQ Sandwich
$4.05
Fish Sandwich
$5.50
Cod Fish
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
$3.25
BLT Sandwich
$4.25
Bacon, lettuce, and tomato.
Steak Sandwich
$4.05

Burgers

Hamburger
$5.25
Double Burger
$6.25
Pizza Burger
$4.75
Mushroom Swiss Burger
$5.75
Hamburger topped with swiss cheese and grilled mushrooms.
BBQ Onion Burger
$5.75
Hamburger topped with 2 onion rings, and bbq sauce.
Cheese Stick Burger
$5.75
Hamburger topped with two cheese sticks, and marinara sauce.

Wings

Wing Dings
$5.50
6 bone in wings.
Boneless Wings
$5.50
6 boneless wings

Sides

Fries
$2.45
Shoestring fries.
Mushrooms
$4.05
Cauliflower
$4.05
Onion Rings
$4.05
Cheese Sticks
$4.05
Poppers
$4.05
Munchers
$4.05
Pickles
$4.05
Funnel Fries
$4.25
Funnel fries coated with powdered sugar.
Loaded Funnel Fries
$5.75
Pasta Salad
$2.50
Chilled salad with a pasta base.
Mac Salad
$2.50
Chips
$1.00

Drinks

Fountain Drink
$1.50
Soda
$3.25
Root beer Float
$4.50
Smoothie
$4.75
Boba Lemonade
$4.50
Bursting Bubble Lemonade
Slushy
$1.50
Edible Chocolate Straw
$1.00
Edible Strawberry Straw
$1.00

Novelties

Chipwich
$4.00
Circus Slice
$2.25
Chocolate Covered Banana
$2.25

Sundaes, Parfaits and More

Twister
$4.50
Soft serve ice cream blended with your choice of candies.
Kids Twister
$3.25
Soft serve ice cream blended with your choice of candies.
Shake
$4.50
Sundae
$3.25
Soft serve ice cream with yo0ur choice of topping.
Banana Split
$5.25
Reese Sundae
$4.25
Vanilla soft serve ice cream, peanut butter, with crushed reese cups on top.
Brownie Sundae
$5.25
Brownie loaded with vanilla ice cream, and hot fudge.
Turtle
$4.25
Vanilla soft serve ice cream with caramel, and hot fudge on top.
Parfait
$4.25
Oreo Disaster
$5.25
A delicious brownie loaded with vanilla soft serve ice cream, marshmallow, hot fudge, and oreos.
Almond Delight
$4.25
Spanish Parfait
$4.25
Pecan Royal
$4.25
Ice Burg
$4.75
Vanilla soft serve ice cream, and slushy with your choice of slushy flavor, all mixed together.
Hot Fudge Cake
$5.50

Ice Cream

Soft Serve Ice Cream
$1.25
Soft Serve Ice Cream served in a bowl.
Dole Whip Ice Cream
$0.85
Hard Dip Ice Cream
$3.50
Hard Dip Ice Cream served in a bowl.
Doggy Sundae
$1.50
Vanilla soft serve ice cream with a doggie bone on top.

Breakfast

Breakfast Toast
$4.00
Served on Brioche
Breakfast Sandwich
$4.00
Coffee
$2.00
Hot black coffee
Orange Juice
$2.00
Hot Chocolate
$2.00

Fetter's Dairy Isle offers a delicious selection of comfort food that’s sure to satisfy any craving, with an emphasis on fresh ingredients and bold flavors. Start with their sandwiches, where the classic Hot Dog takes center stage, perfectly grilled and served in a soft, warm bun. If you’re in the mood for something more substantial, the Foot Long Hot Dog stretches your taste buds with its generous size, or you can opt for the Coney Dog, topped with savory chili and cheese, delivering a satisfying and savory bite with every mouthful.

For burger enthusiasts, Fetter’s Dairy Isle doesn’t disappoint. The Hamburger is a simple yet satisfying choice, with a juicy patty and all the classic fixings. If you’re looking for a meatier experience, their Double Burger is a great option—two perfectly seasoned patties stacked high and served with your favorite toppings. And for something truly unique, the Pizza Burger is a must-try, combining the best of both worlds with pizza sauce, melted cheese, and a tender beef patty that’s sure to delight.

When it comes to wings, Fetter's Dairy Isle offers a variety of options to cater to every taste. Wing Dings are a crispy, golden treat, packed with flavor, while their Boneless Wings provide the same great taste without the hassle of bones. Each wing option is ideal for sharing or enjoying as a standalone meal, with the option to customize the sauce and spice level to your liking.

Whether you’re stopping in for a quick bite or settling in for a leisurely meal, Fetter’s Dairy Isle’s menu offers a range of satisfying choices that are perfect for any occasion.

Fetter's Dairy Isle

Discover Fetter's Dairy Isle in Newark, OH, a hidden gem offering a wide range of mouthwatering sandwiches, burgers, wings, and most importantly, unique ice cream creations like coffee soft serve and cocoa pebble twists. Enjoy the cozy outdoor seating, convenient takeout options, and a menu filled with delectable treats that will keep you coming back for more. Don't miss out on the must-try funnel fries and flavorful blizzards in this charming dairy isle hotspot!

Follow Us
  • facebook
  • Yelp
Copyright 2025 All rights reserved.